Educators are sounding the alarm that artificial intelligence use by students is leading to degraded thinking skills. What are the consequences of outsourcing our thinking in this way?
While A.I. is the latest and most extreme example of this, humans have been using various tools to lighten their cognitive load for hundreds, or maybe even thousands, of years.
Prior to the advent of cheap and easy printing of books, the primary way to share stories was to recite them from memory. But our ability to memorize long passages of text has decreased substantially in our modern world.
Similarly, light, portable, accurate calculators made obsolete the slide rule, which replaced the abacus. The current generation of math students don’t have the same opportunity to develop mental skills for manipulation of numbers that previous generations did.
Does anyone still use maps? The omnipresence of GPS in cars and smartphones has led to a sharp decrease in our ability to read maps, and simplified the mental model we have in our heads of roads and neighborhoods.
The list goes on. Spell-checkers have produced a generation of substandard spellers. Smart phones keep track of telephone numbers we need, so don’t memorize them. Sparknotes negates the need to do your own reading analysis. And so on.
These tools all have upside. They can increase speed, accuracy, and introduce opportunity for people lacking various skills. However, they do have a downside: as we reduce our cognitive load, we also reduce our cognitive skills.
Will we pay a price, as a society, for outsourcing our thinking? Will there come a day when reading, writing, and mathematics abilities are degraded to a dangerous extent? Or will A.I. and other tools open new pathways for humanity to follow?
Related questions: What skills have you lost due to technology? How do you learn? How can we be more productive? What is legitimate use of artificial intelligence?